For Defining Modulus of Subgrade in SAFE see the 1st pic in attachment
As in the figure you uploaded for punching shear results it is clear that u are getting values of the ratio more than 1 which is not oK ..As far as the 5' thickness u have specified for this Raft is too much ..Kindly check the Loadings in ETABs
For interpreting the ETABs Results see the 1st picture in Attaachment
As far as choosing a torsional constant for a member see the second doc. in attachmetns
Torsional Constant for Beams in ETABs .docx
WaoOO Its near my Town
Yup the Bridge undergone Servicebility Failure long time ago and the middle pier is settling from time to time as the scour is happening, when there is good amount of water flowing around its pier.